Unknown's avatar

About djgrieser

I have been Rector of Grace Episcopal Church in Madison, WI since 2009. I'm passionate about Jesus Christ and about connecting our faith and tradition with 21st century culture. I'm also very active in advocating for our homeless neighbors.

Advent 2, Year C

Blessed be the Lord

Advent 2, yr C

December 6, 2009

I sometimes think Advent is like being in a time warp. If you pay close attention to the readings, and the season, it’s very disorienting. First, there’s the fact that Advent is a season about two different comings—the coming of Christmas, the birth of Jesus Christ, and also about the second coming, Christ coming in majesty. Are we looking backward two thousand years, or looking ahead to who knows how many years? Or are we looking forward just two and a half weeks to Christmas Eve? Which is it?

And then there’s the reality that the world around us is in the midst of Christmas, while we are still in Advent. Advent and Christmas are two quite distinct seasons of the church year. In Advent, we wear purple, a penitential color, while Christmas is festive white, for celebration. We shouldn’t even be saying “Merry Christmas” until Christmas Eve.

If that weren’t enough, Luke adds another layer of time for us in today’s lessons. We are in year C of the three-year lectionary cycle, so we are reading for most of the year from the Gospel of Luke. Luke was written later than the gospel of Mark, which was the focal gospel last year, in year B. Like Matthew, Luke builds on Mark, relies on its overall framework, but adds considerable material. Even more importantly, Luke was not content with only writing a gospel. He wrote what was in essence a two-volume work that includes the book of Acts, and tells the story of Jesus Christ and the early church that is carefully constructed. For example, Luke uses a geographical framework that takes the story from Bethlehem, to Galilee, to Jerusalem, and ultimately to Rome and the world.

Luke is also concerned to connect the story of Jesus Christ and the early church with themes from the Jewish tradition and the Hebrew Bible. Nowhere is that more true than in Luke’s version of the story of Jesus’ birth. There are themes, images, and motifs that return us to the Hebrew Bible again. The song of Mary for example, the magnificat, is by and large a reworking of the song of Hannah from I Samuel, which she sang after giving birth to her longed for son, Samuel.

These themes and resonances come out especially in the story of John the Baptist. Luke depicts him as the last of the Hebrew prophets, dressed as they dressed, delivering a message straight from their works. But perhaps the strongest example of the connection between past and present, between God’s working in the history of Israel and God’s working in the present is the song of Zechariah, which we read together a few minutes ago: “Blessed is the Lord the God of Israel, he has come to his people and set them free.”

These words of Zechariah were the first words he spoke after first hearing that his wife would give birth nine months earlier. It is his response when his son John is circumcised, and one can imagine someone thinking for those nine months of just what to say if he ever got his voice back.

In fact, the words are Luke’s creation and demonstrate Luke’s powers as a writer and poet. Luke ties the birth of John to salvation history, to the story of God’s mighty acts in saving God’s people.

If you are familiar with the Daily Office, especially with the service of Morning Prayer, and I would encourage you to familiarize yourself with it; you would recognize the Song of Zechariah as one of the canticles that are recited or sung on a regular basis. It was in that context that I became familiar with those words, and other wonderful biblical hymns, like the Song of Simeon. As is so often the case, when we repeat things often enough we can memorize them. Sometimes memorization means that we never pay attention to the words, but it can also mean that those words become engraved in our memory, and come back to us often and at random.

Our lessons today, and throughout Advent, are full of such familiar words. “For he is like a refiner’s fire” or “And he shall purify” from the Malachi reading, and of course, Handel’s Messiah. We know them from Messiah but barely notice what they are saying. “Who can endure the day of his coming and who can stand when he appears? The images Malachi presents us with seem full of violence and the promise of the destruction of God’s enemies. Even the words of Zechariah seem directed at the same end. God promised to save God’s people from their enemies. Violence and destruction lurk just beneath the text.

And of course, there is violence to in the imagery used by John the Baptizer. John leaves the settled area of Palestine, leaves Jerusalem for the wilderness, where he takes potshots at the culture he has abandoned and threatens the coming of destruction from God. He demands repentance and promises a world upended by divine intervention: “every valley shall be filled and every mountain and hill made low.”

Violence, too, lurks just beyond the world of the text. Luke takes great care to place his narrative in the political context of the Roman Empire. He is writing after Rome has brutally suppressed the Jewish revolt and destroyed the Temple. Luke is writing with those terrible events in mind and one of his goals is to offer an alternative. That may be why he so carefully and completely delineates the powers arrayed against John, and by extension against. He lists seven names, beginning with the emperor Tiberius, and extending downward to Pilate and Herod, and including in the mix the high priest. Seven powers challenged by a voice, crying in the wilderness.

Rome promises violence and oppression, Zechariah hopes for a God who will deliver God’s people, will save them from their enemies. The nature of that salvation isn’t completely clear. Perhaps it will be violent, but the end will be radically different. Zechariah’s hymn ends with the hope that God’s tender compassion will come down from and how and that God will “to guide our feet into the way of peace.” In fact, peace is one of Luke’s central themes. He uses the word more often than all of the other gospels combined.

I couldn’t help thinking of that promise of peace this week. It is a sentiment we hear repeatedly this time of year, the words of the angels in Luke’s gospel easily roll off our tongues “Peace on earth, good will toward all.” Yet we live in a world in which there is no peace; our nation continues to be at war, increasing its military presence in Afghanistan with no end in sight and apparently no real plan nor real hope for bringing stability and order to that part of the world. Apparently, we fight because we fight.

It’s hard for us to take peace seriously in such a world, it’s hard to believe that God’s in-breaking into the world might bring peace. It’s hard to even imagine what it might be like for us to have a faith like Zechariah’s. In some ways, we might understand John a little better. We might imagine ourselves, or a different version of ourselves, getting so tired of everything—the religious establishment, the political establishment, a culture that focuses on White House party crashers and adulterous golfers rather than the intractable problems that face us as a society and a world community—we can imagine getting so sick and tired of everything that we go off into the woods, or go crazy, and start preaching on a street corner or screaming from that wilderness that it’s all going to come to an end.

We might even think that John is somehow more faithful and more responsible than Zechariah, his father. Last week, I talked about the irrelevance and futility of lighting advent candles in the growing December darkness. I spoke of the difficulty of paying attention to that light, of how hard it was to discern the signs of the times.

Zechariah saw, and knew. In the baby that was born to him and Elizabeth in their old age, he recognized the dawn from on high breaking in and he expressed his hope and faith that God would deliver God’s people. His hope was not a hope limited to himself, to his family, or even to his religious and ethnic group. His hope of peace and salvation ultimately extended to the whole world, even to the universe. Such a hope is the hope of Advent. Such hope should be our hope now and always.

Collect for the first Sunday of Advent

Almighty God, give us grace that we may cast away the works of darkness, and put upon us the armor of light, now in the time of this mortal life in which thy Son Jesus Christ came to visit us in great humility; that in the last day, when he shall come again in his glorious majesty to judge both the quick and the dead, we may rise to the life immortal; through him who lives and reigns with thee and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen.

The prayer book collects are a wonderful spur to reflection. Having said them over the years, they strike me anew each time with power. That is especially true of the collects for the Sundays in Advent. I mentioned in my sermon the contrast between the candles we light on the Advent Wreath and the growing darkness of the season. This collect draws on that imagery, too. It’s been running through my head all week.

According to Hatchett, Commentary on the American Prayer Book, this collect was composed for the 1549 Book of Common Prayer. The juxtaposition of dark and light, as well as the emphasis on the contrast between now “in the time of this mortal life” and “the last day” remind us of the poles of our existence. They remind us, too, of the sharply different times in which we live, this present time, and God’s time, or eternity.

The beginning of Advent marks the beginning of the liturgical year, which takes us each year from the expectation of the birth of Jesus Christ, through his death and resurrection, to the birth of the Church at Pentecost. That annual remembering of the story with its incessant yearning for us to return to those events, to participate in them is challenged by another powerful force in the Christian message–the urge to look forward to the second coming. Those are two very different attitudes towards time, and occasionally they leave Christians feeling schizophrenic. Where should our real focus be? On the past, or the future?

Perhaps our focus should be somewhere else entirely. God exists outside of time and created time in the process of creating all things.

Reflections on Catholics and Episcopalians

James Carroll has written eloquently about his own faith journey and about the history of the Catholic Church in Constantine’s Sword, which I heartily recommend to everyone.  He blogs today about the increasingly right-ward turn of the Roman Catholic hierarchy in the US. His observations are here.

His comments provide a fascinating juxtaposition with a couple of recent encounters I’ve had. One was on Saturday, with someone who came by during our open doors. We talked for a few minutes; he was clearly interested in Grace only for its aesthetics, and left after mentioning he was Roman Catholic and attended Latin Mass.

Another man came by last week and asked if we heard confessions. I made an appointment with him, and we talked this morning. He grew up Catholic, was divorced, and needed to get something off of his chest. I doubt whether he could have faced a Roman Catholic priest in a confessional, but we had a lovely conversation, that ended with me offering him absolution.

In the twenty-first century, people are going to make sense of their spiritual lives from their own perspectives, with the wide variety of resources available to them. Some will be drawn to and accept the rigid, hierarchical, authoritarian approach of traditional Catholicism or fundamentalist Protestantism. Others will search elsewhere.

Another opponent of a church providing services to the homeless sues

In Houston, the Beacon, a ministry of the Episcopal Cathedral, provides lunch and other services to as many as 400 homeless people on Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays. A lawyer in an adjacent building doesn’t like the mess, so he has sued, seeking a permanent injunction. It’s not like the Church hasn’t reached out to neighbors. They have an off-duty cop on premises during open hours, and they meet regularly with neighboring businesses. Apparently the lawyer never attended any of those meetings, or communicated directly with the Church. The article is here.

Yes, homelessness is messy. Yes, the sight of homeless people standing around is unattractive. Unfortunately, we live in a society where, for a set of complex reasons, people live on the streets. The answer is not to close facilities, or move them somewhere else, out of sight and out of mind. And above all, the answer is not to prevent the church from doing its mission of feeding the hungry, clothing the naked, and providing shelter to the homeless.

Signs of the Times: Advent 1, Year C

The Signs of the Times

Advent 1, Yr C

November 29, 2009

 

There were many things that I never got used to in fifteen years of living in the South. Grits, for example. I first tasted grits when I visited Corrie’s parents just after our engagement. There was this mess of off-white something on my breakfast plate the first morning I was there. Politely, I had a spoonful. Tasteless, with the texture of wallpaper paste, I swallowed. It was the last taste of grits I had for many years. I avoided them assiduously, even refusing them vocally in a buffet line in Charleston, leading to a delightful interchange with Natalie Dupree, the doyenne of Southern cooking.

In fact, the list of things about the south I never grew accustomed to is quite long. If pressed, I might be able to come up with a similar list of things I liked. But one of the oddest things was the way Southerners approached, or didn’t approach, winter. As a native Midwesterner, with a dozen years in Massachusetts under my belt; I knew what to do when October came around: You got out the storm windows, you made sure you knew where the snow shovel was, and all of your winter clothes, and coats, and the like. You should have gotten the car winterized. In the south, none of that is necessary.

In the south, in South Carolina, where we lived for the last decade, when November came around, life continued pretty much like it had in the previous months. In fact, often by late October or November, it was actually cool enough that you could enjoy the outdoors after a summer of 90+ degree weather.

The only times people actually gave a thought to what winter might bring were when weather forecasters promised snow or ice. Then, everyone got into high gear, making sure that all of the grocery stores were sold out of bread and milk, long before the first snowflake or ice pellet appeared in the sky.

As a somewhat snobbish northerner, I came to think that the climate had shaped Southern culture and character in negative ways. Not needing the annual discipline of careful preparation for a bitter winter, many Southerners tend to approach all of life with a somewhat lackadaisical, carefree attitude. What are the consequences down the road of some decision we make now? Who cares, we’ll deal with that when the time comes. Don’t worry, be happy.

They may be hardnosed businessmen and women, but if it’s a really nice day, many would be inclined to take it off for a round of golf or a day at the beach. One could call it “flip-flop” culture; the tendency to wear overly casual clothes, summer clothes deep into the winter. Of course, one need only drive down University Avenue once to see flip-flop culture’s advance north—as students everywhere seem to have adopted that mode of footwear.

It’s hard work to get ready for winter. I’m beginning to remember that, even though we are renting. We don’t own a house and have all of those preparations. I did, finally put on the storm doors over the weekend. Hey, don’t criticize me, these were the first two solid, consecutive days off I’ve had since moving here. We’ve got a cord of wood laid in; we’ve been out shopping for new winter coats, winter clothes, boots, and the like. I think we’re ready, but not psychologically.

We think about the hard work of getting ready for Christmas—the shopping, the party planning, the decorating, and we may think that when we come to church, we can leave all of that hard work behind us and enjoy another year’s worth of Advent music and upbeat sermons. But Advent is hard work too. Advent is all about preparation, about getting ready. But it’s about more than that. More than that, it’s also about paying attention.

In today’s gospel, Jesus warns his disciples to be on the lookout. Be on guard, be alert, Jesus cautions his listeners. Today’s reading comes from what scholars call the little apocalypse; a sermon that is common to Matthew, Mark, and Luke, in which Jesus tells his disciples about coming events. It’s called an apocalypse, because it, like the book of revelation and parts of Daniel, including the section we read last Sunday, focus on events that are promised to take place in the near future.

Now there’s a lot I could say about apocalyptic, I once taught a course on the topic, but what’s important for us to understand is that apocalyptic presupposes a cataclysmic end to the world as we know it. It posits an eternal battle between the forces of good and evil, and in the end, a final victory of good over evil. Most scholars argue that in spite of all of the predictions that seem to linger in apocalyptic literature, it’s actually more focused on what has already happening, or what is happening right as the author is writing.

In fact, most of us are probably uncomfortable with apocalyptic language and unless we’ve attended church services regularly over the years, and paid attention to the readings, chances are we’re wondering what this gospel lesson has to do with the coming of Christmas. Where’s the joy? Where’s the party?

In fact, Advent is about two comings. Yes, we look forward to the incarnation, the birth of Jesus Christ in Bethlehem; but of course, when we do that, we are really looking back to events that took place more than two millennia ago. Advent is not just about preparing us for Christmas. It is also about the second coming, the coming of Jesus Christ at the end of the age, an event we all proclaim our faith in every time we recite the Nicene creed.

The symbol we use to mark the first Sunday of Advent, a single candle, is a reminder to us of all that Advent means. We may miss its significance in a well-lighted church, but by itself, one advent candle shines brightly in the darkness. It reminds us of the darkening world in which we live, as the days grow shorter and we near the winter solstice, the shortest day of the year. But it takes effort to notice it; we are easily distracted away from that single candle toward other things.

Jesus warns his disciples about being distracted, and about missing the meaning of the signs they are seeing: “There will be signs in the sun, the moon, and the stars, and on the earth distress among nations confused by the roaring of the sea and the waves. People will faint from fear and foreboding of what is coming upon the world, for the powers of the heavens will be shaken.” On first blush, the language and the imagery may startle us. We may be inclined to dismiss it as nothing more than another example of apocalyptic language that has no place in our lives. Yet the resonances are real, and it may be that by dismissing it as apocalyptic, we lose sight of the real power behind the words.

“Signs in the sun, moon, and stars, nations confused by the roaring of the sea and the waves?” This sounds a great deal like the very world we live in, a world in which we are reminded again and again of the destructive forces of nature, and the extent to which we humans have brought destruction to our world. Our climate is changing; the scarce natural resources from which we live are vanishing at an alarming rate; our food supply is endangered by all manner of threat. But for the most part, we go about our daily lives, oblivious to the future, oblivious to the myriad ways in which our decisions every day contribute to ultimate global catastrophe.

Those problems seem quite distant from us. Instead, we focus on our own concerns, our own lives, and however much we might pay lip service to the world around us, we do everything in our power to keep all those fears, all that uncertainty, all that change as far away from us and our families as possible.

But my brothers and sisters, think about it for a second. Such attitudes fly in the face of the evidence around us. At some point, our personal hopes and expectations are going to meet up against the cold, hard, reality of the world. Try as we might, be it by willful ignorance, by blinding ourselves through entertainment, or relentless consumption, we might try to keep the world at bay. But it has its way of breaking in upon us, reminding us that all our efforts at avoiding pain and suffering will come to nought.

But it still breaks in upon us. The world surprises us at every turn. We have lit one faint candle, a sign of hope in a darkening world. There may be no clearer symbol of the meaning of this season of Advent than to light the advent wreath. In this time of the year, as we move toward the winter solstice and the shortest day of the year, we defy the inevitability of our darkening world by lighting candles each week. We light candles, proclaiming our faith that in spite of the darkening world around us, we look for the coming of the Light of the World.

Our every tendency may be to ignore the suffering in the world around us. There’s nothing we can do about it; the problems seem so great and intractable. Our impulse is to circle the wagons, retreat inside our homes, perhaps even inside of our gated communities and there to live life to the fullest, perhaps assuaging our guilt with an extra donation of money in this season of giving. But our faith does not let us do that.

Think about that candle again. Think about the irrelevance, the meaninglessness of lighting a single candle in the growing darkness of December. How can that dispel the gloom of a winter’s day? Yet we do it, each year. Each year we proclaim our faith in the Light of the World. We proclaim our faith that our redemption is near as we light the candles of the Advent Wreath. A simple, insignificant act like that should give us hope that all of our actions, no matter how small and insignificant may also contribute to the redemption of the world.

new data on foodstamp usage

There’s an article in the NY Times about the enormous increase in the usage of foodstamps. The numbers are startling. For Dane County, 7% of the population relies on food stamps; 15% of children; 51% of African Americans. In other counties I have lived: Greenville County, SC: 12% overall 24% of children; 31% of African Americans. In Elkhart County, IN usage has increased 75% since 2007. The article and the interactive map are here.

I’m reading Mark Winne’s Closing the Food Gap: Resetting the Table in the Land of Plenty. Winne was for many years director of the Hartford Food System in Hartford, CT and describes the many problems associated with the attempts by non-profits to provide food for the food-insecure. I’ll have more to say about this later, but he is critical of the food pantry and food bank system on a number of grounds.

Grace has had a food pantry for thirty years. That’s an achievement, whether it deserves to be celebrated or not is another question. Certainly, we’ve fed a lot of people over those years. But it’s a bandaid, and the fact of the matter is that more people are food-insecure today than ever before, and as Winne and others point out, the food pantry system is constructed in such a way that it makes volunteers feel good, the nonprofits that serve the hungry feel good, and it gives the food producers that provide food for the pantries an outlet for product they don’t want. Winne argues that if all of that volunteer energy were directed toward solving the underlying issues of hunger and poverty, more progress would be made in the long run.

Advent

I have blogged in previous years about the colors of Advent, about some of the fairly new traditions of Advent, including the Advent wreath here.

Traditionally, Advent was a penitential season, much like Lent, hence the use of the same liturgical color, purple, in both seasons. Recent liturgical changes have downplayed its penitential aspect and emphasized the theme of waiting or expectation, as well as being alert.

There’s a profound disconnect between “the holiday season” and Advent, perhaps most apparent in the lectionary readings. One aspect of Advent that remains as true today as ever is that the focus for much of the season is not on the birth of Jesus Christ, but rather on his second coming. Apocalyptic themes predominate. On the first Sunday of Advent, we will hear from Luke’s version of Jesus’ apocalyptic preaching; later, we will hear similar themes from John the Baptist.

The focus on the Second Coming explains the earlier penitential emphasis. But there’s another way of thinking about Advent’s apocalyptic side. The first Sunday of Advent is the Church’s New Year’s Day, the beginning of the liturgical calendar. Advent, first or second, is all about God’s time. We rarely consider the importance of how we think about time. There’s been an enormous cultural transformation in recent years. The move from analog to digital in a way masks the passing of time. We don’t watch the hands of the clock moving across the dial, instead we have the constantly flashing beacon of led displays.

A couple of years ago, one of my colleagues was lecturing about the changes in the early modern period that came to the conception of time, and how people related to it. He began the lecture by asking students to tell him what time their watches read. In fact, only a handful of the eighty students had watches. All the rest kept time by their cellphones.

The Holiday Season, with its bustle of activity–shopping, parties, concerts, and the like–each year makes enormous demands on our time. Advent, which sees God breaking into time, breaking into history, twice; once in Bethlehem, the other at some point in the future, reminds us that even as we are slaves to the time of the season, God operates by a very different clock. Indeed, God exists outside of time, and it should be our goal to view time sub specie aeternitatis.

Biblical surprises

I’m always fascinated when I encounter surprises in the biblical text. Today was one such occasion. As I began preparing for the noon Eucharist, I turned to Lesser Feasts and Fasts. November 25 is the commemoration of James Huntington.

As is often the case, when I encounter a figure with whom I am not familiar, I look for alternatives. Tomorrow being Thanksgiving, I checked out the propers for Thanksgiving in Year C. The gospel was immediately approachable: Matthew 6:25-33 which include those wonderful words: Consider the lilies of the field; they neither toil nor spin…” Given the anxiety I was experiencing, trying to make final preparations for Sunday, after having been out of the office all day yesterday, they were words I needed to hear.

But the lesson from Joel was even more fascinating: “Do not fear, O soil; be glad and rejoice, for the LORD has done great things! Do not fear, you animals of the field, for the pastures of the wilderness are green; the tree bears its fruit, the fig tree and vine give their full yield” (Joel 2:21-22). Remarkable words given the overall attitude toward the land and its non-human inhabitants in the Hebrew Bible.

I had to drive to Whitewater yesterday. As I did, I saw fields that had been harvested, cornfields that remained untouched, and farmers here and there picking corn. Our culture has tended to view the land as something to exploit, but Joel’s words suggest a more difficult and complex relationship. Thanksgiving is traditionally a time to enjoy the fruits of one’s labors, the fruits of harvest. We live in a world that is very much divorced from the struggles of farmers, and their work in the fields. But much of our wealth is created on the backs of the poor, and on the backs of those who toil in fields to harvest vegetables and fruits for our tables. We also benefit from a system that exploits animals horribly. Thanksgiving is a hollow holiday indeed if we do not recognize the sacrifices of others (human beings and animals) to make our table full of food.

On praying for the death of one’s enemies

I alluded in my sermon to the current fad in some right-wing Christian circles for merchandise that sports the following: Psalm 109:8 “May his days be few;
may another seize his position.” There’s been considerable discussion in the press concerning this phenomenon. One interesting take on it comes from Frank Schaeffer. You can see it here:

A former colleague of mine at Furman, Shelly Matthews will soon be publishing a book in which she argues that the “forgiveness” prayers, beginning with Jesus’ words on the cross in the Gospel of Luke (“Father forgive them, for they know not what they do”) and continuing with Stephen’s in Acts, are interpreted in early Christianity as just the opposite.

We often hear that Christianity is a religion of peace (usually contrasting with the violence of Islam), yet the fact of the matter is that Biblical language is very violent and can easily be interpreted as Ps. 109:8 seems to be, as advocating God’s destruction of one’s enemies.

We will be hearing again from apocalyptic texts as we do every Advent. Apocalyptic is predicated on the radical opposition between good and evil and the ultimate, and usually very bloody destruction of the enemies of God.

There is another strand of the biblical tradition. It’s seen in Romans 13, the pseudo-Pauline texts, and in I-II Peter: the urge to pray for those in power, because they have been ordained by God. In the long run, that attitude is hardly more comforting than praying for the destruction of one’s enemies. But in fact it is the position that conservative Christianity maintained up until the present.

“Ancient of Days”

Here’s the Blake image I referred to in my Sunday sermon

I mentioned that the shafts of light emanating from the fingers are reminiscent of a compass, which calls to mind Milton’s description in Paradise Lost of God creating the universe:

Then stay’d the fervid Wheels, and in his hand
He took the golden Compasses, prepar’d
In God’s Eternal store, to circumscribe
This Universe, and all created things:
One foot he centred and the other turn’d
Round through the vast profundity obscure,
And said, Thus far extend, thus far thy bounds,
This be thy just Circumference, O World. Paradise Lost VII.224-231

The image of the golden compass has itself become quite familiar in contemporary culture, most prominently in Phillip Pullman’s novel of that name, recently made into a movie.